14°C, rain.
English grammar is in my thoughts around this time- we’re writing reports at work. Add to that a discussion underway on FSDeveloper‘s website and my mind wanders- especially when on the bike. Some of the discussion looks at the differences between British & US English. Consider this:
The Question "Have you got a ticket?"
A British person answers: "Yes, I have."
An American says: " Yes I do" which sounds peculiar to British ears, but why?
The clearest explanation I can think of goes like this:
My answer is shortened from " Yes, I have got a ticket?
So we assume that the US version is shortened from: "Yes I do got a ticket", which is absurd.
It seems that there could be two explanations for this: one is that the American version is wrong. The other is that the Americans could be in the habit of asking the question differently:
"Do you have a ticket?"
However, we don’t always hear that style of question, so that is not a strong hypothesis:
Found a clearly written site that explains a technique for questioning those grammar posers that you have an odd feeling about but aren’t exactly sure why.
Dodge the grammar traps. I like the idea of removing parts to sentences to see if they still work. There are other tests to help trace the problems. Useful.